Toll Brothers opened the Noah Elite model at 3 Flower Horn Blvd. for daily tours in June 2025. It is part of Oaks at Randolph, a community Toll describes as 108 townhomes. Toll's New Jersey community page still lists the community for sale. Prices start at $775,995 for three-bedroom, two-story townhomes of 2,210 to 2,311 square feet with two garages.
That starting price is within a few thousand dollars of the median Morris County single-family sale this fall. For anyone shopping at Oaks, the useful comparison is a resale house, not an older townhome.
The Starting Price Matches a House
The NJ REALTORS Local Market Update for Morris County for October 2026 puts the median single-family sale at $773,000. The median townhouse-condo sale for the same month was $497,500.
| Measure | Price | Period |
|---|---|---|
| Oaks at Randolph, starting price | $775,995 | Current Toll Brothers listing, November 2026 |
| Morris County median single-family sale | $773,000 | October 2026 |
| Morris County median single-family sale | $795,000 | Year to date through October 2026 |
| Morris County median townhouse-condo sale | $497,500 | October 2026 |
| Morris County median townhouse-condo sale | $549,500 | Year to date through October 2026 |
At its starting price, an Oaks townhome costs $2,995 more than the median Morris County single-family house sold in October 2026. It costs about $278,000 more than the median townhouse or condo sold in the county that month. Against the year-to-date figures through October, the starting price is still more than $225,000 above the attached median and about $19,000 below the detached median.
So a buyer touring Oaks is not comparing it with the older townhome resales around the county. At this budget, the realistic alternative is a resale single-family house. These are county figures, because the monthly NJ REALTORS reports break out data by county, and Randolph sits inside that market.
What You'll Likely Pay Is Above the Starting Price
The starting price is the lowest number Toll publishes. The homes you can actually buy and move into soon show a higher one. Toll's quick move-in list for Northern New Jersey shows three Anders Devonshire townhomes at Oaks, each 2,210 square feet with three bedrooms and two garages:
| Home site | Price | Listed move-in |
|---|---|---|
| Home Site 16229, Rasboro Road | $849,000 | January 2027 |
| Home Site 13255, Rasboro Rd. | $834,000 | April 2027 |
| Home Site 13451, Rasboro Rd. | $863,000 | April 2027 |
These three homes are priced $58,005 to $87,005 above the community's starting price. On 2,210 square feet, that comes to roughly $377 to $391 per square foot. For a finished home in a specific spot, those numbers are a fairer guide to the cost than the starting price. Every one of them is above the October median for a Morris County single-family house.
For a buyer, the question at Oaks is whether a brand-new, two-garage townhome is worth $60,000 to $90,000 more than what the typical detached house in the county sold for this fall. A buyer who wants a new build will keep coming back to that question.
What the Price Over Attached Resales Buys
The price gap over the county's attached median buys things a resale rarely has. Toll's 2024 announcement of the community described floor plans up to 2,300 square feet with basement options. The current listing shows two garages on every plan and one to two half-baths on top of the two full baths. You also get new construction, with no previous owner's repairs to inherit.
A resale detached house at the same price is a different trade: a standalone home, along with whatever age and upkeep it carries. Neither choice is better for everyone. Older attached communities sit in a lower price range. Kensington Square, which the Daily Record described as a 105-home townhome community in Randolph when it launched, is one of them.
More Choice This Fall Than Last
The rest of the county market makes this comparison easier to act on than it was a year ago. In October 2026, Morris County had 195 townhouses and condos for sale, up 25.8% from October 2025, and 704 single-family homes for sale, up 18.7%. Both had 2.3 months of supply, compared with 1.9 a year earlier.
Sellers still got their asking price or better. Attached sellers received 101.4% of list price in October 2026, and single-family sellers received 102.9%. Single-family homes took a median of 31 days to sell, and attached homes 33.
Put together, these numbers show that a buyer comparing Oaks with a resale house has more homes to choose from than last fall. Once a buyer settles on a resale, though, they should still expect to pay close to the asking price. A builder's price list works differently. Toll is running a dated sales event for November 7 through 22, 2026. How much room there is to negotiate on a new build is a separate question from how competitive resale offers are.
Randolph's New Construction Is Still Filling In
Oaks is one of several new projects in Randolph, and what gets built around town will shape what Oaks townhomes are compared against later.
WoodBrook at Randolph is a rental community of 102 Signature Carriage Homes and 97 Classic Apartment Flats, and it is leasing now. NorthJersey.com reported that the 199-unit community welcomed its first residents on April 15, 2026, and was nearly 80% leased when it opened. The WoodBrook floor plan page lists rents as "Call for Pricing." For a household not ready to commit $800,000, renting a new unit in Randolph is one more option.
Toll is also planning a second project in town. Randolph Planning Board minutes from May 18, 2026 list application MSP 26-01 from Toll NJ I, LLC for 75 stacked townhomes at 855 Route 10, Block 44/Lot 12, with 15 of them affordable units. A township notice says the Planning Board took action on the application on July 20, 2026, and that its resolution is on file with the Planning Office. Stacked townhomes are a different layout from Oaks' two-story plans.
In Mount Freedom, ROI-NJ reported on January 30, 2026, that OES Properties bought the fully approved site at 1192 Sussex Turnpike from Ludiro Inc. for $4.5 million. The approved plan calls for 25 townhomes plus a three-story mixed-use building with 10 apartments and 4,055 square feet of retail.
Taken together, Randolph's newer attached homes now include for-sale townhomes, carriage-home rentals and approved projects in two parts of town. A buyer choosing Oaks today is picking among the first of these, and the list of new options nearby is likely to grow.
Timing a Purchase Around a Home You Already Own
The quick move-in dates create a practical problem for buyers who already own a home. Move-in dates of January 2027 and April 2027 mean committing to a new home months before you can move into it. A buyer whose down payment is tied up in a current house has to line up two dates: the new home's completion and the old home's sale.
This is where move-up timing tools come in. The team covers how Compass Concierge and related programs fit a sale in its guide to Compass programs. Your home's likely sale price is also where the budget question starts. If a current Randolph house would sell near the county median, its sale price and an Oaks quick move-in price are not far apart, so the move comes down to timing more than money. Treat this as general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and confirm your own financing with a qualified lender or advisor.
If you're deciding whether a new Oaks townhome or a resale house fits your next move, a pricing review of the home you own now makes that comparison concrete. The Tucker Team can tell you where your current home would likely sell in this fall's Morris County market and how that number lines up with a 2027 move-in date. Start with Get Your Home Valuation, or browse current Randolph homes for sale to see the resale houses in the same price range.